Old-Fashioned Pinconning Cheese

Old-Fashioned Pinconning Cheese

Dan Horn pioneered the Old-Fashioned Pinconning Cheese recipe in 1915 and named it after our Northern Michigan city. Today, we still use Dan’s recipe, which begins with natural and nutritious milk. We age Old-Fashioned Pinconning Cheese for as long as 16 years to improve the texture and develop its sharpness. Pinconning Cheese can substitute in most recipes calling for Cheddar or Colby cheeses.

Skip to results list

Active filters:

20 items
Column grid
Column grid

Filter

Active filters:

  • Mild Pinconning off the Wheel

  • Medium Mild Pinconning off the Wheel

  • Medium Sharp Pinconning off the Wheel

  • Sharp Pinconning off the Wheel

  • Extra Sharp Pinconning off the Wheel

  • Super Sharp Pinconning off the Wheel

  • 10 Year Old Super Sharp Pinconning

  • 16 Year Old Pinconning Cheese

  • Smoked Pinconning Cheese

  • 17 Year Old - Super Sharp Reserve Yellow Cheddar

  • 20 Year Old - Ultra Sharp Reserve Yellow Cheddar

  • 10 Year Old - Super Sharp Reserve White Cheddar

  • 17 Year Old - Super Sharp Reserve White Cheddar

  • Tigertown Colby Jack

  • 1 lb. Pinconning Sharp Cheddar with Black Wax Casing

  • 1 lb. Pinconning Medium Cheddar with Red Wax Casing

  • 2.5 lb. Charcuterie Block Gift Item # 23

  • 3 lb. Mini Wheel Mild Pinconning

  • Charcuterie Block Cheese

  • Pinconning Cheese Bread