• Whats on Special!
  • About
  • Contact
  • Customer Service
logologologologo
  • Cheeses
    • Old-Fashioned Pinconning Cheese
    • Pinconning Cheese Curds
    • Homemade Cheese Spreads
    • Flavored Cream Cheese Spreads
    • String Cheese & Whips
    • Other Domestic and Imported Cheeses
    • Flavored Cheeses
    • Smoked Cheeses
    • Swiss Cheeses
    • Hot & Spicy Cheeses
    • Lo Salt and Cholesterol Cheeses
    • High Temperature Cheese
    • Amish Roll Butter
    • Chocolate Cheese
  • Meats & Fish
    • Salami, Pepper and Snack Sticks
    • Summer Sausages
    • Hot Dogs, Bratwurst & Grilling Sausage
    • Koegel Meats
    • Pickled Meats/ Items
    • Michigan Made Meats
    • Michigan Made Jerky
    • Fresh Water Smoked Fish
    • Shelf Stable Meats
    • Other Meats
  • Gifts
    • Gift Boxes & Items
    • T-Shirts & Stuff
    • Gift Cards
  • Fudge & Snacks
    • Homemade Fudge
    • Snacks & Candies
  • World Famous Pizzaloaves
  • Misc. Foods
    • Michigan Made Coney-Chili Sauces
    • Hot Sauces, BBQs, Ketchups, & Salsas
    • Specialty Mustards
    • Pickles, Olives & More
    • Homemade Jams & Jellies
    • Crackers and Chips
    • Pure Michigan Maple Syrup
    • Michigan Made Honey
    • Michigan Made Soda Pops
    • Gourmet Coffee
    • Specialty Spices
    • Amish Pasta
  • Deli
0
✕
            No results See all results

            Shop

            • Home
            • Fudge & Snacks
            • Homemade Jams & Jellies
            • Yoders Pumpkin Butter
            Mrs. Miller’s Orange Marmalade
            08/10/2012
            Z Nothing Beyond Hot Sauce
            08/10/2012
            Yoders Pumpkin Butter

            Yoders Pumpkin Butter

            This sweet and spicy topping isn’t just for breakfast! 9 oz.

            $5.99

            SKU: SKU000925 Categories: Fudge & Snacks, Homemade Jams & Jellies, Misc. Foods
            Share
            • Description
            • Additional information

            Ingredients: Pumpkin, White Sugar, Brown Sugar, Lemon juice, Water, Pectin, Spices.

            Weight 1 lbs

            You may also like…

            • Butterfinger Fudge

              Butterfinger Fudge

              $8.99 – $16.99Price range: $8.99 through $16.99
              Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
            • Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge

              Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge

              $8.99 – $16.99Price range: $8.99 through $16.99
              Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
            • Peanut Butter Fudge

              Peanut Butter Fudge

              $8.99 – $16.99Price range: $8.99 through $16.99
              Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page

            Related products

            • Win Schuler's Garlic Bar Chips

              Win Schuler’s Garlic Bar Chips

              $6.49
              Add to cart
            • Plain Breadsticks

              Plain Breadsticks

              $5.99
              Add to cart
            • 1 lb. Cinnamon Almonds

              1 lb. Cinnamon Almonds

              $12.09
              Add to cart
            Information
            • About Us
            • Contact Us
            • Customer Service
            • Nutritional Facts
            • Payment, Pricing & Promotion
            • Privacy Policy
            • In The News
            Buy From Us
            • Deli Menu
            • Gift Brochure
            • Info / Coupon Brochure
            • Shipping & Returns
            • Wholesale / Fundraising Sales Information
            My Account
            • My account
            • Cart
            • Whats on Special!
            • New Products!
            Newsletter

            Subscribe and Save!

            Store Location

            221 N. Mable St. (M-13)
            Pinconning, MI 48650

            Telephone Orders

            Local: +1 (989) 879-2281
            Toll Free: +1 (800) 678-1962

            Winter Hours

            Mon - Thur: 9 am-7 pm
            Fri - Sat: 9 am-8 pm
            Sun: 10:30 am-7 pm

            Pinconning Cheese Co. & Fudge Shoppe © 2025
            00

            $0.00

                      No results See all results
                      • About
                      • Contact
                      • Customer Service
                      ✕

                      Login

                      Lost your password?

                      Create an account?

                      GET 10% OFF

                      YOUR FIRST ORDER


                      Subscribe to our newsletter

                      This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
                      Name(Required)